Federal Judge Once Again Blocks Revocation of TPS

On Friday, California District Court Judge Edward Chen once again ruled against the Trump administration in its bid to revoke Temporary Protected Status (TPS) from Venezuelan and Haitian nationals, coming into judgment in favor of the plaintiffs in the case styled National TPS Alliance v. Noem. I say “once again” because this is a case that has concerned quite a few procedural twists and rulings (and is not completed yet). 

To give some background on how we obtained to this level: 

• On March 31, Judge Chen entered an order granting the plaintiffs’ (a number of people plus the National TPS Alliance (NTPSA)) movement to postpone Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem’s resolution to vacate the extension of the 2023 Designation and to terminate the 2023 Designation (of Venezuelans as elligible for TPS by the Biden administration — a later amended grievance added the TPS as to Haitians into the combo as effectively).
• The Trump administration appealed that ruling to the ninth Circuit, which, just like the district court, denied the administration’s movement to keep the ruling pending appeal.
• The administration then filed an utility for keep with the U.S. Supreme Court, which, on May 19, granted that utility for keep.  
• On August 29, the ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s postponement order. 

RELATED: Despite Supreme Court Stay, Judge Blocks Trump Admin From Revoking TPS for Thousands of Venezuelans

New: ninth Circuit Affirms Ruling Enjoining Trump Admin. From Revoking TPS Status for Venezuelans

You could also be questioning how the district court may flip around and enter a resolution blocking the administration’s TPS revocation. Well, that’s because the SCOTUS keep applies only to the district court’s order on the movement to postpone — i.e., a preliminary procedural ruling — not a remaining ruling on the deserves. This latest ruling by Judge Chen is an precise judgment/ruling on the deserves. (And it’ll, just like the prior rulings, be appealed.) 

A federal decide has barred the Trump administration from revoking the short-term legal standing for lots of of hundreds of Venezuelan and Haitian immigrants, calling the administration’s bid to solid them out of the nation “unlawful” and based on false rationales.

U.S. District Judge Edward Chen ruled that Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem’s transfer to terminate the “temporary protected status” afforded by the Biden administration was “preordained without any [meaningful] analysis and review.”

The ruling is the latest episode in litigation that has ping-ponged through the federal courts for months. In an earlier section of the case, the Supreme Court permitted one of Noem’s choices on the subject to stand while the litigation proceeded in the decrease courts. That emergency order from the justices lifted a earlier block that Chen had imposed on the TPS revocations.

Chen, an Obama appointee based in San Francisco, said his new ruling didn’t battle with the Supreme Court’s prior order because, at that level, the case was in a preliminary posture, and the justices’ resolution utilized only to a short-term block he had issued. The high court, he wrote, didn’t stop him from totally contemplating the deserves of the case and rendering a remaining judgment on the challengers’ argument that Noem’s coverage change violated the federal law that governs company decisionmaking.

As famous, the choice will undoubtedly be appealed to the ninth Circuit, and from there back up to ths Supreme Court, so there are still a number of more chapters to come in this TPS saga. RedState will, of course, continue to observe along and report on any notable developments. 

Editor’s Note: Radical leftist judges are doing every little thing they’ll to hamstring President Trump’s agenda to make America great again.

Help us maintain these corrupt judges accountable for their unconstitutional rulings. Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your membership.